This is a long post about Batman’s allergy issues that I’ve been meaning to write for some time. We’re starting to see some improvement with the help of a holistic vet, using Chinese herbal remedies and food therapy. I know allergies affect a lot of pets these days, particularly German Shepherds, and I hope our experience proves helpful to others.
This all started about 4 months ago, while we were still in DC. Batman developed an ear infection (yeast and bacterial) that spread to his upper body and back. He was treated with antibiotics, and the infection went away. However, he continued to scratch and started developing hotspots, and would stink within a day of getting a bath. He’d just turned 1, and up until this point had almost no health issues.
But after that first ear infection, his health problems seemed to snowball. He started dropping weight, losing 13lbs in 3 months. He kept getting itchier, losing hair on his beautiful ears, and his coat grew dull, flaky and smelly.
It doesn’t seem to be a hereditary issue; his littermates are doing fine. My suspicion is that environmental toxins in DC (bad air and water quality, pesticides, and other pollutants) played a role. I don’t think any of Batman’s littermates were raised in an urban environment, so that seems to be the most obvious explanatory variable.
Since we moved to CA, it’s gotten better, but the infections keep recurring. I get the sense that we’re stuck in a cycle, and conventional veterinary medicine can no longer prescribe us out of it. This is no disrespect to any of our DVMs, I just feel that we need to attack this from a different angle, and we’ve reached the upper limit of what conventional veterinary medicine can do for us.
We’ve taken a long and frustrating route to get here, which I detail below. You’ll have to scroll down to get to the holistic intervention – we’ve had so many vet visits and prescriptions, it’s easiest to list them chronologically:
October 1, 2012 – Weight: 82lbs. Lab tests reveal bacterial and yeast infections in Batman’s ears, likely resulting from his birthday swim trip (this is how I learned that you must always clean out your dog’s ears after swimming). He’s lost a lot of hair on his ears (alopecia), especially on the edges. Vet prescribes Mometamax ear drops and Cephalexin oral antibiotics, and oral Ivermectin for possible mange. I switch his diet from Honest Kitchen Love (beef) to HK Zeal (whitefish).
October 15, 2012 – Weight: 79lbs. Vet gives Batman a clean bill of health. Ear infection is gone, though he still has alopecia on his ears, and mange spots on his muzzle.
November 2, 2012 – I notice that he is itching and chewing himself on his sides, and developing hotspots. I call the vet, and they give me a cone for him, and tell me to call if it gets worse. I switch him from HK Zeal to Primal Raw Beef and Lamb formulas.
November 12, 2012 – Weight: 75lbs. Back to the vet for a skin scraping, which comes back negative for mites. Vet thinks it is allergies and recommends giving Benedryl. Vet prescribes Temaril-P, a steroid, which I (thankfully) do not administer.
November 22, 2012 – Tired of wasting good Benedryl on Batman, I switch his diet to Primal Raw Turkey and Sardines. I also start giving him filtered or bottled water instead of tap water.
November 27, 2012 – IS: 8. I go to a holistic pet boutique and talk to the owner about Batman’s condition. She recommends Answers Raw Pork and raw goat’s milk, so I switch him again. She said I need to be patient, and it will take a few weeks before I should expect to see changes. I start keeping a journal to track his food and supplements, and give each day an “Itch Score” (IS) on a scale of 1-10, with 1 being itch-free, and 10 being non-stop itching.
December 3, 2012 – IS: 6. Itching has gone down a little, but there are five new hotspots on Batman’s back and sides. I consult with a friend for homeopathic recommendations, and start administering thuja and rhus tox on his gums for the next week. I wash all of his bedding in plain water in case he’s reacting to detergent residue, and sell all the rugs in the house (we’re in the process of moving). I also increase his exercise to 90 minutes a day.
December 6, 2012 – IS: 2. The least amount of scratching in months. He has two new hotspots on his thigh, but I see light at the end of the tunnel. Not sure if it’s the raw pork or increased exercise or homeopathic remedies, but something is helping.
December 17, 2012 – IS: 4. We start our cross-country drive, and I have to take him off the Answers Raw Pork. I put him on OC Rabbit.
December 20, 2012 – IS: 7. He is getting abrasions on his ears from itching them so much. I suspect the ear infection is back and administer Mometamex. Switch to Primal Raw Venison since we’re on the road, and I have to get whatever I can find. I thought venison would be a good novel protein (this is totally wrong, btw).
December 23, 2012 – IS: 7. Made it to California. I start him on a 2-week raw pork and zucchini elimination diet.
December 24, 2012 – Weight: 69lbs. IS: 8. I take him to a new vet because his ear infection looks like it’s getting worse. She confirms that he has become resistant to the Mometamex and prescribes Posatex. I’m shocked to discover that Batman has lost 13lbs in the last 3 months. I up his food to 2lbs per day.
January 8, 2013 – Weight: 70lbs. IS: 7. I take him to another vet for his Distemper and Parvo 3-year vaccine, and also for a second opinion on his continually itchy skin. She prescribes another round of antibiotics (Cephalexin) because the yeast infections on his body are back. The vet isn’t concerned about his weight, but I am and increase his food to 2.25 lbs per day. He’s on a homemade raw beef and veggies diet.
January 14, 2013 – IS: 3. Antibiotics are kicking in.
January 25, 2013 – IS: 8. I made the mistake of giving Batman processed treats, Natural Balance Lamb, earlier in the week and he’s paying for it now. I later discover that NB Lamb is the worst possible treat I could have fed him.
January 28, 2013 – Weight: 72lbs. IS: 7. I take Batman to a holistic vet, who is a licensed DVM, acupuncturist and practitioner of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). She also has over a decade of experience working with German Shepherds as a U.S. Army veterinarian. We like her. She has a plan for us:
- Eliminate all foods that cause a heating response in the body. This includes venison, lamb, beef and buffalo. Venison and lamb are particularly heating. Since Batman has a condition of damp heat, he should be fed a diet of cooling proteins. She recommended turkey or rabbit. Duck and fish are also cooling proteins.
- Cook his food. The vet recommends the raw diet to healthy dogs, but Batman is not healthy enough to process the pathogens in raw meat right now. Meat should be cooked through slowly at a low temperature and served at room temperature or warmer. Vet recommends Stella and Chewy’s Rabbit frozen patties, cooked at 350 degrees, or cooking organic turkey or rabbit from the butcher. I start with turkey because it’s more affordable and easier to find, but will try S&C Rabbit next week.
- Reduce the amount of meat, and add brown rice and veggies. Feed a ratio of 1/3 cooked meat, 1/3 brown rice, and 1/3 veggies (Sojo’s and Honest Kitchen make good veggie mixes), and feed him more because he needs to gain at least 5lbs. When he’s underweight, it’s even harder for his immune system to recover.
- Hold off on all vaccines until he is healthy.
- Continue to supplement with Omega3s, probiotics and enzymes.
- Wash his ears with a 50/50 solution of Bragg’s apple cider vinegar (ACV) once per week.
- Bathe, at most, once every 3 weeks (the dog, that is).
The vet also prescribed two Chinese herbal remedies, GI Tonic and Gentiana Compound, to reduce the damp heat in his body.
It’s only been 5 days, and I’ve already seen an improvement. Batman is noticeably less itchy, and his ears are looking better. My parents noticed that he doesn’t smell as bad, even though I haven’t given him a bath in 2 weeks. His skin is less flaky. He’s definitely gaining weight (I’ve upped his food to 3lbs with a target of about 1,800 calories per day, not including training treats) — he’s still very trim, but looks healthier.
I’m optimistic that we’ll kick this thing without the use of more antibiotics and drugs. I made a table to keep track of his food intake, supplements and how he’s doing on the IS scale everyday. We’ll see the vet again in a week for a progress report. Hopefully I’ll have good news after that.
